Flashback Friday: Where would you like some Separator Posts?

Long before separated cycleways were commonplace around Christchurch, one way to improve the level of comfort with existing painted cycle lanes was to add some occasional vertical posts to keep errant motorists at bay. Even now, this relatively low-cost measure has the potential to improve the perception of the traditional cycle network. But where to install them? This post, originally from Jan 2014, elicited many responses – in fact, to date it has easily been our most commented on post…

A few weeks ago we talked about the City Council’s “Targeted Improvements” (or “Quick Wins”) programme that is being rolled out. One of the tools that fits in very well with this programme is cycle lane separators, as previously trialled in a couple of places in Christchurch. Now the Council would like some feedback on where some more could go in.

These seem to work well – so where should we put some more?

If you recall, the intention with these separators is to make existing cycle lanes friendlier to use by actively discouraging/preventing motorists from encroaching on them. Typical locations are:

  1. On the inside of a curve, where traffic cuts the corner
  2. On the approach to an intersection, where left-turning traffic blocks the cycle lane

Following on from the successful trials at two locations, the City Council are keen to identify further locations where problems exist that the separators could improve. From this they want to create a list of candidate sites that will then be assessed for prioritising and implementation.

A combination of low “Riley kerb” and high “flexi-post” delineators was previously trialled but, for now, the intention is to just use the flexi-posts. At some locations, sandblasting and re-marking of cycle lanes will also be needed to achieve desirable widths (the posts do have the effect of narrowing the perceived available cycling width). Current funding this financial year might only achieve about 10 intersections (say, two approaches to each) and maybe another 12 curved cycle lane sites. The amount of funding for these in the 2014/15 year will be reviewed later.

Some flexi-posts and Riley kerbs in action at an intersection

It’s important to appreciate that these separators won’t necessarily be the best option for every location. Complications like parking and driveways for example may make some locations tricky. Ultimately on the Major Cycleway Routes we may be looking for a higher standard of cycleway to attract new riders, e.g. using more physical separation. Flexi-posts are a very cost-effective option to improve the cycling environment, but they may not be a sufficient level of cycleway separation in every case.

Some of the more notable factors that should be considered for suitable sites include:

  • Routes that form part of the planned cycling network in the Chch Transport Strategic Plan.
  • High rates of cycle lane encroachment by motor vehicles
  • No adjacent on-street parking or major accessways
  • Locations predominantly for “everyday” cycling, with good cycle count numbers
  • Sufficient advanced visibility of the separators (so they don’t become a hazard in their own right)
  • An adequate width cycle lane (or available space to make it suficiently wide)
  • Probably not preferred in higher speed environments (say, >60km/h)
  • Ideally not sites that will be reconstructed again soon (e.g. SCIRT works), although they could be an interim pre-cursor to a later Major Cycleway Route.

It couldn’t hurt either if the sites were in locations where they can be very conspicuous to the general public as well (e.g. on busier roads or near major activity centres) – a high profile for cycleway projects is all good PR…

Not just the Major Cycleways – plenty of other routes are part of Chch’s planned cycleway network

Based on previous Council investigations and your fantastic feedback to our earlier posts, the City Council already has a fairly good list of potential sites for separators. For example:

  • Various inside curves along Centaurus Rd, e.g. #141, #206
  • New Brighton Rd / Marshlands Rd intersection eastern approach
  • Antigua St / Moorhouse Ave intersection north/south approaches
  • Memorial Ave cycle lane near exit from Fendalton Mall
  • Various inside curves along Wairakei Road, e.g. #40, #96
  • Annex Road lefthand into Birmingham Drive
  • Clyde Rd / Creyke Rd intersection – north/south approaches
  • Bealey/Fitzgerald/London/Whitmore intersection approaches
  • Kahu Road bridge @ Deans Bush
  • Greers/Northcote/Saywers Arms intersection east approach
  • Ilam/Middleton/Riccarton intersection north/south departures
  • Lincoln/Lyttelton/Wrights intersection NW/SE departures

If you have some ideas for where these separators could go, post a comment on this page (“me too” comments supporting previous suggestions would also be helpful). We’ll make sure that the City Council has a look at the collated suggestions.

Milton/Strickland intersection – another potential site?

Note that the sites have to be on local (Council-controlled) roads, not (NZTA controlled) State Highways. So that rules out the likes of Brougham St, Halswell Rd, Dyers Rd, Curletts Rd, Yaldhurst Rd, etc. You can still always contact NZTA to raise any concerns about cycling issues on the State Highways – see our separate post about reporting issues to other roading agencies. Maybe they’ll take the hint and incorporate some separators along the State Hwy cycle lanes…

Where else would you like to see some cycle lane separators?

7 thoughts on “Flashback Friday: Where would you like some Separator Posts?”

  1. Some separators would be great on both sides of Lyttelton street at the intersection of Sparks road and Frankleigh street. Cars are always taking up the green painted cycle lane when turning left.

  2. Yes please regarding all those already listed and suggested above!
    Also the intersection of Strowan Rd/Rossall St and Heaton St/Glandovey Rd – ideally all approaches, but primarily Strowan/Rossall.
    Lots of points along Wairakei Rd in addition to the two above, e.g. #204, 119-143, either side of the railway line (both directions), intersection of Strowan and Normans Roads, heading SE.
    #12 Rossall St plus no parking yellow lines alongside Rhodes St properties opposite the river (cars park here illegally all the time).
    That’s most of my side of town. We should ask Waimakariri and Selwyn District Councils to do the same! Rangiora is terrible to cycle through, as is Lincoln.
    Wheels to Wings is hopefully coming soon, but the Bishopdale roundabout is terrible!
    #11-#17 Greers Road.
    Northcote Rd becoming Greers Rd heading W/SW.
    #83 Shands Road.

  3. For the THIRD time this year I have reported the disappearance of the cycle separator post that it is just on the town side of Ferrymead Bridge where motorists heading to Ferry Rd cut across cyclists heading to Hunphreys Drive. There is a separated bike lane for cyclists heading to Ferry Rd. That the post keeps getting damaged suggests to me that it is needed.

    I like the separator posts – they are much cheaper to fix/replace than cyclists.

  4. Opposite 102B Clyde Rd, just north of Creyke Rd as the road bends to the left. Drivers always cut the corner into the cycle lane. It is also an entrance to Medbury School, but just before the school entrance would keep drivers out of the cycle lane.

  5. 500 Papanui Rd, city-bound, the road curves from Main North Road onto Papanui Rd, and drivers turning right from Harewood Rd onto Papanui Rd (like all right hand turns) take a bad line and end up in the cycle lane.
    The Harewood/Main North/Papanui intersection in general is terrible for driver road placement.

  6. #122 Straven Road
    #1 Te Kura St/Straven Road cycle lane
    #Intersection of Straven Road and Kilmarnock St/Kahu Rd (all directions)
    #Intersection of Riccarton Rd and Straven Rd/Clarence St (where possible, i.e. the cycle lanes that are not shared cycle/turning lanes)
    #Intersection of Clarence St and Dilworth St
    #Intersection of Blenheim Rd and Clarence St/Whiteleigh Ave (all directions)
    #Intersection of Lincoln Road and Whiteleigh Ave/Barrington St (all directions)
    #Intersection of Barrington St and Brougham St slip lanes
    #446 Barrington St
    #Intersection of Barrington St and Milton/Frankleigh Sts

  7. #Intersection of Greers Road and Waimairi Road (cycle lane on Waimairi)
    #Several bends along Main Road between Sumner and Ferrymead in both directions

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *